Mike's Wretched Hive of Scum & Villany
The Original
DarkWhiteWolf
AKA Mike In Boise

Blog EntryAn Answer to a Fitness Chicken or Egg QuestionJun 1, '08 12:09 PM
for everyone

A near always asked question by new exercisers is what should I do first my cardio or my resistance training. Like all experts I will answer with the positive and absolute statement of "it depends." MUHAHAHAHAHAHA!

Actually it pretty set in stone depending on your goals. In freshman level classes you learn the SAID principle. Specific Adaptation to Implied Demands. Simply means you body will adapt to exactly what you do, no more than it has to. Knowing this we can plan how to include exercises that give you the most bang for buck as they say.

Most my clients are seniors or the obese. To maximize weight loss, and regain lost physical functioning, I insist on doing resistance first. Here is why. Once warmed up your body will be most capable of doing what you do first, meaning better output potential, the ability to work out a bit harder.  Ability to work harder means more adaptations. Building a pound of muscle is 35 calories used perday even if you sit on your duff! They used to tell differently, they used to say do cardio first. Now that we know more that is not the case.  Can you lose weight doing 30 mins cardio at 60% heart rate followed by 3 sets of ten resistance? Yes you can, but....

Second reason is for weight loss, doing your resistance first delete your glycogen reserves, your carbs, the sugar in your blood. So when you go on to do your cardio next, your body must use more fat as fuel and attempt to conserve carbs. Your post exercise burn. EPOC Post Exercise Oxygen Consumption will be higher. That is like free fat loss after your work out. Think of it as interest earned on your workout investment. Your body soon learns it will need to be more active, and will attempt to save carbs to work out, carbs are the preferred fuel over fats or protein. So while just going about your day, you are burning fat, more fat than those lazy bones that do not work out.

Athletes need to do the focus of the day first while having fresh legs to get the most out of the work out, and to be fresh to avoid injury. Like where I am training for distance I run first then do resistance MWF, and an abdominal circuit T-TH. I need to get used to high output at the end of the race with depleted blood glucose. I am not really an athlete, but you get the picture. Where a football player (NFL type) would do explosive sprints or lifts on days opposite of skill drills. A five mile run is pointless, and asking for injury.

Typical work out

10 mins warm up circuit jumping jacks, elbow to knee, free hand squats, stair steps, ect ect ect

resistance exercises like off the floor lifts, lunges, overhead presses, bench or cable presses, pull up or lat pulls, about 20 mins

30 mins cardio of what ever gets you going

10 mins stretching to cool down. (no, we also no longer stretch before working out, this is found to weaken the muscle before it ever works, causes micro tears before activity)


6 Comments
drhouse2008 wrote on Jun 1
I really dig science,

my wife is an esthetican and gives skin care to her clients/customers, persuadeing them to give her money for treatment and product, and to do this, she has to explain the science of what she or the products are doing, and the benefit to them the buyer

what you did with this blog is explain the science and the benefit of warming up, lifting weights, and then running or swimming or bikeing, then the cool down

i totally dig it,

i don't think its so much a praise of science, but a praise of the way you have applied science, similar to how my wife does

kudos man
crkincalifornia wrote on Jun 1
would I lose weight if I got someone to do it for me? lol just kidding. This is good to know in case I ever decide to become athletic. Unfortunately I think the only way for us soft people, unless they do find a thyroid problem, is for us to starve ourselves. aye aye aye
direwolfghost wrote on Jun 1
starving is never the answer, jsut do what you can, the rewards are great. You mentioned jsut walking cut back your low back pain. So keep up with that, maybe find a hill to walk up a couple days per week. Dont for get your stretches to help with low back pain as well.
direwolfghost wrote on Jun 1
I want to give the best knowledge I can. All the snake oil hookey fitness crap sold out there I feel I have to re-earn a reputation as a reliable cource.
Thanks for the compliment!
happyathome wrote on Jun 1
Thanks for this Mike. Haven't gone to a gym or had a trainer in years so the changes (resistance before cardio, no need to stretch before working out) are new to me.
debosofi wrote on Jun 3
If I didn't love the way my skin shimmered after a brisk walk from my front door to my letterbox, I would exercise more :D
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help